Comments on: Open letter to Suman Chatterjee aka Kabir Suman

By: LoRai

LoRai — Sun, 25 Oct 2009 07:16:50 +0000

Suman is still there…u can still stand there where you were holding and conceiving an identity…sometimes, a man has to do what he is gotta do…if u look deep inside, u will know…u will…

but as Abe Lincoln said: Never explain, your friends never need them, and your enemies wouldn’t believe them anyway…

you gotta trust this man…if he is a part of ur identity…i am not saying blindly…but with a little more subtlety u know…

By: koushik

koushik — Thu, 08 Oct 2009 10:33:28 +0000

ja hocche bhalor jannai hocche.

By: bigbangbong

bigbangbong — Thu, 01 Oct 2009 07:41:59 +0000

Dear Pro9 – I don’t have time and energy to chase your half boiled remarks and comments. So whatever you think – go ahead, you are no longer welcome here…

Cheers!

By: bigbangbong

bigbangbong — Wed, 30 Sep 2009 00:30:00 +0000

Shubho bijoya to you too. Thanks for dropping by and spend a long time here. Just few comments:

1. As you are a self proclaimed ‘die-hard fan’ of Suman, we can’t expect neutrality from you – can we? So what’s the fuss?

2. Multi party allied government is not a sign of a matured democracy. None of the countries with developed democratic governance system have multi-pary alliance.

3. Last time I checked this is our blog, and we have the right to write whatever we feel. If you fail to notice that we restrain ourselves from moderating ‘opponent’ and/or ‘opposite’ viewpoints, I am really sorry for you.

4. You should immediately stop paying your English tutor, who couldn’t teach you the difference between “sheet” and “shit”. Or may be it’s your cognitive limitation. As you said, I am a bit confused and doubtful person.

The problem with the world is the stupid are cocksure and the intelligent are full of doubt.

Cheers!

By: Pro9

Pro9 — Tue, 29 Sep 2009 17:26:19 +0000

Respected bigbangbong,
The more I read what you’ve written,the more I get confused.I don’t know what you have opened the blog for.Is it to teach us how to use Caps Lock or tell us about your knowledge.It’s damn sheet.The more you think and write,the more you get deviated from the topic of discussion.
I am a die-hard fan of Suman.Entering the field of Politics is nothing new to a person who had created innumerable songs on his political views. Suman is aperson who had always stood up against the wrong,he should not be judged by his companion Mamata(whom you think to be a fanatic).You did not have any obligation when you saw him first in a leftist brigade meeting.Why do you have it now then?Is it because he had gone against his former co-mates.Then same is your case.The man from whom you have drawn inspiration is now like your worst enemy because he has changed sides to fight against the wrong.
Do you support what the leftist government is doing?Do you support their practices which are just contrary to what their ideals were.It may be your opinion that if we support the Trinamool,it will still be as bad.Same are my views.But we need to stand up against the fascist C.P.I.M government and give the opposition an opportunity because they have never got once.Do you think that the C.P.I.M corporaton under Bikash Bhattacharya is better than that of T.M.C’s under Subrata Mukherjee?Okay,let’s not get deviated from what your supposed basic topic is.
Yes,it’s a social decision of Suman’s to join the politics but it his personal decision to be on the side of Mamata Banerjee.You may not like her but this can’t be the basis for your hatred towards the man whom you once loved and respected the most.
When I read your blog I see you supporting the people who are of your view,not even thinking twice whether they are staunch supporters of communism which you say you are not,but showing utter disrespect for those who are not of your view.If this is what you have learnt from Suman,then it’s good for us that you are no longer a Suman fan.But still your hatred cannot dimilish the worth of his Lyrics,the value of his songs and the rich diversity he brought into Bengali songs.
One kind request to you,please don’t take the pain of correcting my English because I have an English tutor who is taking care of this.The last lines,that you are deleting Suman’s songs from your music library shows us that you have never realized their worth because you may hate Suman as a person,but his lyrics are high above your narrow feelings and political views.Don’t take me otherwise,but after reading your blog I have only one thing to say,”Thou art a royal fool!”I’m intentionally using Shakespearean English to show respect to your vast knowledge.

By: bigbangbong

bigbangbong — Sun, 20 Sep 2009 12:59:00 +0000

I wonder how far you can go when you are behind the veil of internet anonymity. Keep it up bro…BTW – I liked your definition “bong bong emotional foolish blog” – Thinking of changing the tagline to this.
Cheers!

By: SD

SD — Sun, 20 Sep 2009 02:36:19 +0000

Pretty stupid bong bong emotional foolish blog.
Congrats!
The last line is superb: I am deleting songs blah blah blah…
What a moron>>>>>>>>

By: Mousumi

Mousumi — Wed, 22 Jul 2009 10:35:36 +0000

Suman, let us talk about commanlities first…what do i have in common with you..my surname, my cousin being too. Now, differences…well yes, Trinamool… But let’s not dig into that. Suman, those were the days when teens dreamt of revolution all around when you sang, loud or just in whispers. These are still the days when my song would slip into his world of dreams at bed with your songs ringing in his ears. But as parents when we sing we keep low key as you rightly said “slogan paalte hoye jaae fishfaash”… as if you could foresee the future of one of our commonalities, the sound of music. Trinamool, I understand, is getting back to the roots, of problems, disruptions, stagnancy, and then bloom as flowers…like your songs did…long time back.

Now, we see you in poster, at one corner where you beg for political support from people who were already yours through your music…why did you have to crave, did you really realize lately that “prem paaltaae, shorir o paalte jaae…”. The corpus of the music lovers and their expressions have changed Suman, not because of your entering the political cauldron, but because of the sound of your music changing to noise. After all, “Jodi bhabo kincho amaai bhul bhebecho..”

Votes are yours already, you don’t have to really go begging and seeking for it…all we need is you to go seeking for that Suman who once sang music with courage and created charisma…not with cowardice. After all Suman, if not you, I will have to justify the lullaby I sing to my song every night…Or else, he will say “raater kobita sesh kore daao…”. And I can alreay foresee the difference it is going to create in my life…

By: bigbangbong

bigbangbong — Sun, 24 May 2009 11:24:40 +0000

All quiet at western front!

By: Tinkerbell

Tinkerbell — Sat, 23 May 2009 20:48:31 +0000

Finally, it’s quiet here